Arts &
  Arts Culture Analysis  
Vol. 9, No. 4, 2010
  Current Issue  
  Back Issues  
Robert J. Lewis
  Senior Editor
Mark Goldfarb
  Contributing Editors
Bernard Dubé
Sylvain Richard
Nancy Snipper
David Solway
Marissa Consiglieri de Chackal
  Music Editors
Diane Gordon
Serge Gamache
  Arts Editor
Lydia Schrufer
Mady Bourdage
Marcel Dubois
Emanuel Pordes
  Past Contributors
  Noam Chomsky
Mark Kingwell
David Solway
Naomi Klein
Arundhati Roy
Evelyn Lau
Stephen Lewis
Robert Fisk
Margaret Somverville
Michael Moore
Julius Grey
Irshad Manji
Richard Rodriguez
Pico Iyer
Edward Said
Jean Baudrillard
Bill Moyers
Barbara Ehrenreich
Leon Wieseltier
Nayan Chanda
Charles Lewis
John Lavery
Tariq Ali
Michael Albert
Rochelle Gurstein
Alex Waterhouse-Hayward

debate over


Maywa Montenegro



Maywa Montenegro is an editor at Seed Magazine.


Political scientist Robert Paarlberg sparked a small firestorm on the web with an essay in Foreign Policy taking aim at the organic, local, and slow food movements -- a “cause célèbre that is advocating the wrong recipe for helping to feed those who need it most.” Touching on topics he has written about at length in two books (Starved for Science and Food Politics), Paarlberg rejected claims that organic foods are either more nutritious or safer to eat, and argued that organic farming could turn out to be environmentally disastrous:

“Less than one percent of American cropland is under organic production. If the other 99 percent were to switch to organic and had to fertilize crops without any synthetic nitrogen fertilizer, the US cattle population would have to increase roughly fivefold. And because those animals would have to be raised organically on forage crops, much of the land in the lower 48 states would need to be converted to pasture.” An all-organic Europe, he writes, would need an additional 28 million hectares of cropland -- equal to all of the remaining forest in France, Germany, Britain, and Denmark.

Paarlberg’s biggest beef, however, has to do with the developing world, and especially Africa. Elitist foodies in the US and Europe, he believes, are promoting a low-tech approach to agriculture that is effectively undermining African development. “A new line of thinking has emerged that opposes bringing improved seeds and fertilizers to traditional farmers and linking those farmers to international markets,” he wrote, arguing that such thinking poses a grave threat to global food security -- and is all the more absurd considering that Africans already have a de-facto organic food system, where food is purchased and sold locally, uses very little chemical inputs, and is prepared in a painfully slow fashion.

“If we are going to get serious about solving global hunger, we need to de-romanticize our view of pre-industrial food and farming,” Paarlberg wrote. “And that means learning to appreciate the modern, science-intensive, and highly capitalized agricultural system we’ve developed in the West.”

Not surprisingly, Paarlberg’s piece elicited immediate outcry from the alternative agriculture community. In addition to the flurry of comments on Foreign Policy’s own website, and experts writing extensive critiques on e-mail listservs, there was a formal rebuttal published the following day by Anna Lappé, daughter of the renowned environmental justice activist Frances Moore Lappé and co-founder of the Small Planet Institute.

Lappé’s counter-argument centered on a number of scientific studies indicating that it is indeed possible to feed the world using a variety of organic and agro-ecological methods of farming. She pointed to a multi-year, multi-disciplinary study by Catherine Badgely and colleagues at the University of Michigan, which concluded that a hypothetical worldwide alternative agriculture system could produce between 95 and 157 percent of the calories presently produced -- without agricultural expansion and with no net increased use of resources. Researchers at the University of Essex who analyzed 287 projects in 57 countries found similar improvements with a transition to less resource-intensive agriculture. And the seminal IAASTD report -- engaging 400 scientists and development experts from 80 nations over a period of four years -- also determined that “resource-extractive industrial agriculture is risky and unsustainable, particularly in the face of worsening climate, energy, and water crises.”

At Seed Magazine, we’ve long been fascinated by the intense debate over the future of food. What does “sustainable agriculture” truly mean -- and what should it look like? Given the tensions between achieving global food security and limiting the environmental impacts of food production, what kind of system can meet both challenges? And as we watched this most recent media eruption play out, we were frustrated by what appears to be ongoing orange-to-apples comparisons. One person’s definition of “organic” was not the same as another’s. Some peer-reviewed studies show that organic and agro-ecological farming can feed the world in 2050. Other, seemingly equally valid studies, indicate that this can’t possibly be true.

In an effort to make sense of conflicting information, and to get beyond the tit-for-tat towards meaningful dialogue, Seed invited Dr. Paarlberg to participate in an Oxford-style debate with Dr. M. Jahi Chappell, a co-author on the Badgely paper that supported an important role for organic agriculture in contributing to the global food supply.

For the results, please consult the following links:

Round I

Round II

Related articles:
The Row Over Raw Food

Oceans Drowning in Plastic

Cell Phone Users Beware
Chicken Belittled
Roil Over Olive Oil
Teflon and Your Toxicity
Omnivore's Dilemma
Slice and Salmon Lice
Steroid Hysteria
The Soya Bean Conspiracy
Can Red Meat Take the Heat?



BENEFIT CONCERT FOR HAITI, SALLE GESU, JAN. 20TH (Papa Groove, Ariane Moffatt, Bďa, Kodiak, Echo Kalypso, Doriane Fabrig (ex-Dobacaracol), Claude Lamothe, Ian Kelly, Pépé: Box-office 514.861.4036 = shared webhosting, dedicated servers, development/consulting, no down time/top security, exceptional prices
Film Ratings Page of Sylvain Richard, film critic at Arts & Opinion - Montreal
2009 Montreal International Blues Festival - Aug. 12 - 16th: (Patsy Gallent, Martin Deschamps, Jim Zeller, Carl Tremblay, The Porn Flakes etc.). border=
Montreal World Film Festival
Festival Nouveau Cinema de Montreal, Oct. 10-21st, (514) 844-2172
CINEMANIA(Montreal) - festival de films francophone 1-11 novembre, Cinema Imperial info@514-878-0082: featuring Bernard Tavernier
Montreal Jazz Festival
Montreal Guitar Show July 2-4th (Sylvain Luc etc.). border=
Listing + Ratings of films from festivals, art houses, indie
Armand Vaillancourt: sculptor
Available Ad Space
Valid HTML 4.01!
Privacy Statement Contact Info
Copyright 2002 Robert J. Lewis