Arts &
  Arts Culture Analysis  
Vol. 7, No. 6, 2008
  Current Issue  
  Back Issues  
Robert J. Lewis
  Senior Editor
Mark Goldfarb
  Contributing Editors
Bernard Dubé
Diane Gordon
Robert Rotondo
Sylvain Richard
Marissa Consiglieri de Chackal
  Music Editors
Emanuel Pordes
Serge Gamache
  Arts Editor
Lydia Schrufer
Mady Bourdage
Marcel Dubois
Emanuel Pordes
  Past Contributors
  Noam Chomsky
Mark Kingwell
Naomi Klein
Arundhati Roy
Evelyn Lau
Stephen Lewis
Robert Fisk
David Solway
Michael Moore
Julius Grey
Irshad Manji
Richard Rodriguez
Pico Iyer
Edward Said
Jean Baudrillard
Bill Moyers
Barbara Ehrenreich
Leon Wieseltier
Charles Lewis
John Lavery
Tariq Ali
Michael Albert
Rochelle Gurstein
Alex Waterhouse-Hayward


AUTHOR NOTE: In the title, Cain reigns over Gaza. In the Bible, Cain killed Abel. God did not approve, and neither do I.
Why the obvious should require so much re-stating is beyond me, but thanks for taking on the task.
This time I find it doubly depressing in view of the madness that prevails elsewhere: the markets, Russia and even Stephane Dion. How happy I would be if, during this last 20 or (hopefully) 30 years of my life, I could see the world putting to good use the lessons of history. But I trust no one anymore.
What, you ask in your article, pushes a people to walk straight into the jaws of death? My answer: the sense that the whole is greater than any of its individual parts. A people is an organism, and as with any organism, it will, if necessary, sacrifice any of its singular elements for the sake of the whole. This argument challenges mathematical logic. It is not utilitarian. It is founded on love of nation. A deep rooted sense of having "a common and unique homeland, history and heritage, language and literature, song and story, traditions and customs.” When these are taken from you as the world turns a blind eye (or worse yet, encourages the pillaging, as is the case with the Radical American Evangelical Movement, a cultist racist movement which has done more damage to Christianity than anything I can think of), it is not inconceivable that a people react -- and react most irrationally.
Extremely well-written: Bravo! You have expressed so eloquently everything that I know to be true and wish was common knowledge in the United States and the rest of the world that is hell bent on blaming Israel for everything gone wrong in the Middle East.
Great piece - I still like the idea of giving the Israelis New Jersey and Florida, and leave Israel to the Palestinians. Nostradamus was right!
The fulchrum upon which your whole argument turns--Hamas vs. Israel = Iran vs Israel = Arabs vs Jews--is purely and simply an error of fact. Iran is not Arab.

from Jeffrey Aarles
Your "God-awful in Gaza" article reads as though Goliath were innocently standing by picking his teeth while David insists on throwing rocks until the big guy finally lost his patience. You might want to read a couple of good articles on the situation. Here are three suggestions:
I've enjoyed Arts & Opinion, but this ill-thought through and utterly insensitive article has infuriated me. Please UNSUBSCRIBE me. Happy bloody New Year.

from Shahidul Alam
A relevant addition to the story. The smaller man is lying on the ground fighting for his breath, while Arnold is standing on him choking him, having weakened him in the first place, by cutting off his food supply. Over the years, Arnold has also killed many of his relatives and friends, and happens to occupy his land forcibly.
With a kid majoring in Islamic studies, your article was hotly discussed in this household. Ok, the Arabs have indeed used the Palestinians as pawns in their battle royale with Israel. But why did this happen? Because Israel stole Palestine. After WWII, one can't blame the Jews for being, ummm, proactive in establishing a state. I have heard Israeli settlers saying such rubbish as, "Of course this is our land - God gave it to us." Well, it ain't their land. I hold out for the New Jersey-Florida solution. I would have rather seen the US offer every Jew in tarnation a safe place to live in this country rather than cause the ruckus in the Middle East. This didn't happen, did it? I know more than a handful of people who have colourful international family backgrounds due to their inability to escape to the US during the Holocaust. There will never be peace in Israel. The only way it would have worked out is if the Israelis did what the US did to the Indians, and that didn't happen. I was surprised to see a couple of pro-Palestinian demonstrations in Massachusetts, given our support of Israel. I guess "Plan B" is for the Arab countries to take in the Palestinians, but I think it's only Jordan that does. What a mess. I just hope it this doesn't become WWIII.
You know, Robert, one can hardly argue with you. History holds many similar examples of the suicidal betrayals of whole peoples by their leaders. Your point is well made. For example, how dare those damned Indians resist white Christian civilization's march across Turtle Island!? Their leaders only brought destruction down on their own peoples. Sitting Bull, you know, was really the one responsible for the massacre at Wounded Knee -- not the US government or the bent on revenge 7th Cavalry; and clearly, Crazy Horse should never have thrown those rocks at Custer in the first place. You don't do that to white superheroes and cultural and moral giants, after all.

This essay is despicable tripe -- tripe verging on evil -- however banal and trivial the effort.

from abuyussif
Take the analogy a step further, how would one want to help the little man whom you perceive (rightly or wrongly) is being bullied? Would you spend all your time criticizing the strong man or would you advise the little, mentally incompetent man to try to agree to some sort of compromise that would get the strong one to stop pounding his face to a bloody pulp from time to time?
When you are dealing with someone who is willing to die for his rights, what can be said to him?Iif no price is too great to pay (even paying that price, to him, is a privilege), why even get involved? Stupid is as stupid does, and if someone wants to get the life beaten out of himself because of stupidity, let him; and the danger is that the more you get involved in trying to help, the more likely you’ll be on the receiving end of the little man’s foolishness.
Sorry, but I’m not really seeing what the problem is here. Palestinians are playing the world like a fiddle, but they know the west loves self-flagellation and only wants to gratify all involved.

from Cynic
But is not just Iran and its friends; it is also Western Europe and the US who have gone along as spectators.
Actually until 1950 the Brits did a lot to try and destroy a Jewish lifestyle in the region.
They could have done something 60 years ago to stop the use of “permanent refugees” as canon fodder by the Arab League.
They permitted the creation of UNWRA which serves no other purpose than to sustain the grinding machine.
They have poured billions of $ into the extremist camp over the years and have done nothing about this logistical support that the PLO and Hamas have received.
And the stupid public cannot see that the Emperor is naked.
In Robert J. Lewis's thought experiment, the 150 pound man continually tosses rocks at Arnold Schwarzenegger type, perhaps in the belief that the Arnold Schwarzenegger type is a civilized "gentle giant", concerned about his own strength, who will tolerate such annoyance without responding. However, the Palestinians are even more removed from reality than the hypothetical 150 pound man.

This suggests a society that has a typical attribute of the angry adolescent. The final step from adolescence to adulthood requires an emotionally meaningful understanding of the concept that every cause has an effect. In other words, one's behavior has consequences in the real world. The Palestinians behave as if they do not understand this. The lack of a conceptual understanding of cause and effect animates much of Arab culture and is an integral part of Islam as currently understood in the fundamentalist world. The concept of Inshallah, Allah's will, specifically precludes cause and effect and free will. The codification of cause and effect, beginning with the early Judeo-Christian idea that G-d has established a rational universe, later as defined by Newton's laws of motion, especially the idea that "every action has an equal and opposite reaction", is part of the Western cultural core. Western children grow up in a milieu that includes an implicit understanding of cause and effect, an understanding that becomes refined through the years and ultimately is deeply internalized by the Western adult. When there is no cause and effect, the adolescent insistence on experiencing the world as one would prefer rather than as it actually exists, becomes extremely problematic. How can you teach a child that their behavior has consequences when they are explicitly taught by their teachers that all that matters is Allah's will? In such a case, like a Western adolescent, there is no agency, no free will, and no concern of consequences.
Here's an illustration: Google for 'chuhas.' These are children who have been deliberately deformed by iron head squeezers, to elicit money by begging. They are also called Rat Children. The Palestinians are the political Rat Children of the Middle East.



falls mainly





 = shared webhosting, dedicated servers, development/consulting
Montreal World Film Festival
Couleur JAZZ 91.9
2007 Millennium Summit, Montreal, Nov. 8-9, info =  1.866.515.5009
Armand Vaillancourt: sculptor
E-Tango: Web Design and lowest rates for web hosting
Available Ad Space
Care + Net Computer Services
Valid HTML 4.01!
Privacy Statement Contact Info
Copyright 2002 Robert J. Lewis